173
Instructor’s Guide – Transferring Blame
Overview:
This story is about implementing a follow-up plan when patients are transferred across hospital units or discharged to ensure that their care history is documented and passed on. It also highlights the importance of listening to what patients tell you about their care.
Primary Learning Outcomes
After completing this lesson, the student will be able to:
- Describe the process for information follow-up when patients are transferred into or out of the unit.
- Examine how information and communication gaps can contribute to preventable readmissions.
- Create a plan for involving the patient as a team member by actively soliciting and validating information from them about their prior medications and care.
QSEN Pre-Licensure Competencies
The following QSEN competencies are addressed in this lesson:
- Patient-Centered Care: Recognize the patient or designee as the source of control and full partner in providing compassionate and coordinated care based on respect for patient’s preferences, values, and needs.
- Teamwork and Collaboration: Function effectively within nursing and inter-professional teams, fostering open communication, mutual respect, and shared decision-making to achieve quality patient care.
Students will answer reflection questions upon completing the story. These questions are aligned with the QSEN competencies and are designed to help the student reflect on both the content of the story and the QSEN competencies addressed by the story.
*Following each question are some potential answers
- What information and communication gaps occurred among the medical staff in this story?
A: There were several issues that occurred in this story. Angela did not have the medical records from the previous infusion center and she did not call the doctor to get an order for an antiemetic, even though the patient asked for it. This situation may have been avoided if Angela would have looked at the previous chemo administration record and called the doctor for an antiemetic order.
- What steps could this unit have taken to ensure that team members had access to all necessary information about patients when they transfer into the unit, and that they know who to talk to when information is missing?
A: One way this can be done is by having all medical records sent to the office prior to the patient being seen. Another way would be to hold off on the medication administration until the medical records are received. The patient should have been the focus of the scenario and not the nurse and doctor blaming other people for the lack of information.
- What does this story illustrate about the importance of actively soliciting and validating information from patients about their prior medications and care?
A: There was a great deal of unspoken communication during this scenario due to the fact that nurse did not have all of the information. This situation may have been avoided if there were standards in place prior to chemo administration.
Discussion Questions:
Use discussion questions for face to face or online discussion boards to get students to further reflect on the content of the story together.
*Following each question are some potential answers
- What can we learn from this story?
A: Harm occurred to a patient because the nurse was trying to provide care for her patient, but did not use appropriate communication. She could have avoided this scenario if she would have waited for the appropriate checks to be made instead of rushing forward with her work.
- What can you do to ensure that you seek patient input about their medications and care?
A: The nurse did not follow through with the information that had been provided by the patient. If everyone were responsible for their own behavior this situation may have turned out differently. It is important for the nurse and other health care professionals to communicate clearly with the patient regarding their care.
Suggested Classroom Mastery Activities:
These activities can be tailored for individuals or groups in a face to face or online setting.
- Create a flowchart for what you believe should happen when a patient is transferred to the unit in this story. Who should have what information, when, and why?
- Develop a presentation or brochure for patients about the importance of sharing their prior medications and care with their new healthcare providers, especially when being transferred from one unit to another.
Measuring Student Mastery:
Learning Outcome | Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 |
Describe the process for information follow-up when patients are transferred into or out of the unit. | Student struggles to describe the process for information follow-up when patients are transferred into or out of the unit. | Student can describe the process for information follow-up when patients are transferred into or out of the unit, but needs further practice. | Student can accurately describe the process for information follow-up when patients are transferred into or out of the unit. |
Examine how information and communication gaps can contribute to preventable readmissions. | Student struggles to examine how information and communication gaps can contribute to preventable readmissions. | Student can examine how information and communication gaps can contribute to preventable readmissions, but needs further practice. | Student can accurately examine how information and communication gaps can contribute to preventable readmissions. |
Create a plan for involving the patient as a team member by actively soliciting and validating information from them about their prior medications and care. | Student struggles to create a plan for involving the patient as a team member by actively soliciting and validating information from them about their prior medications and care. | Student can create a plan for involving the patient as a team member by actively soliciting and validating information from them about their prior medications and care, but needs further practice. | Student can accurately create a plan for involving the patient as a team member by actively soliciting and validating information from them about their prior medications and care. |
Additional Story-Specific Resources:
For additional information on improving team communication, please consult the following articles and resources in Further Reading:
- Professional Behavior Resources
- Professional Conduct Survey
- Improving Teamwork and Communication with TeamSTEPPS
- Berwick on Patient Centeredness
- Achieving an Exceptional Patient and Family Experience of Inpatient Hospital Care
- TeamSTEPPS Essentials
- The Human Factor: The critical importance of effective teamwork and communication in providing safe care.
Story-Specific Best Practices and Proven Tools:
In addition to the ideas generated by students and mentioned in the activities, there are established best practices that may be appropriate to introduce or reference during this lesson to support communication. Some best practices to consider for improving team communication include:
- Check-Backs
- Collaboration
- Cross Monitoring
- Handoff
- I PASS the BATON
- 3Ws – Who I am, What I am Doing, and Why I Care
- AskMe3
- “Speak Up”